This may also be harder to manage as youd have to add the mac for each desktop into the xendesktop delivery centre console, vs using auto provisioning via xenserver for example then deliver the virtual client via the citrix receiver how does esx vdi stack up. Vmware horizon is easier to manage, uses fewer servers, and only two software interfaces. For administrators who have deployed citrix xenapp and xendesktop in the past. Xenapp is citrixs rds system and has bee around since the beginning of time metaframe etc. Comparison between horizon cloud and citrix cloud on azure posted by marius sandbu november 3, 2017 in uncategorized the last couple of weeks i have been working with vmware horizon cloud for microsoft azure, and tesing the bits and pieces about the platform, and especially ive been looking at how it compares against citrix cloud in general. Lets check out citrix s four reasons to go beyond vmware horizon with citrix xenapp and xendesktop whitepaper. One of the most interesting plays that vmware has with horizon 6, is the ability to present resources through horizon workspace from citrix xenapp. Vmware workspace one is a better choice than citrix.
Enterprises want to be able to provide macos vms to remote users while keeping data and intellectual property in the data center. Unlike vmware horizon, citrix virtual apps and desktops provides the industryleading support for unified communication uc solutions, such as microsoft skype for business, cisco jabber or avaya onex, used by more than 7550 0,000 active users per day. Hi all, i am ruining two poc, one for citrix xenapp and xendesktop, the second if for vmware horizon suite view and workspace i am a big fan of vmware, but i can tell that the flexibility of citrix is much better than vmware in the terms of byod. Vmware worked, but slower and not as consistently with device redirection. My initial knee jerk reaction was why would you want to move from xenapp xendesktop to view.
Breaking down the daas offerings from amazon, vmware. Trusted platform for reduced risk and lower costs from the desktop through the data center to the cloud, only vmware offers an endtoend platform based on the industryleading softwaredefined data center vmware vsphere, vmware virtual san, and vmware nsx. Citrix ended up bringing back xenapp in 2014, but in the meantime vmware seized the opportunity to elbow its way into the app remoting market with horizon 6. Dare to compare citrix xenapp vs vmware horizon skype for business. Unlike vmware horizon, citrix virtual apps and desktops provides the industryleading support for unified communication uc solutions, such as microsoft skype for business, cisco jabber or avaya onex, used by more than 75 50 0,000 active users per day. With vdi virtual desktop infrastructure, as the saying goes, whats old. Citrix xendesktop is a product that aims to allow coupling of cloudcomputing with desktop and application virtualization, reaching high levels of resource optimization and infrastructure agility, as well as costeffectiveness. Can vmwares horizon 6 go toetotoe with citrix xendesktop. Deciding between vmware horizon 6 and citrix xendesktop. Citrix vdiinabox, formerly known as kaviza, is citrix s entry level vdi solution. This is something that citrix xendesktop cannot do. Breaking down the daas offerings from amazon, vmware, microsoft, and citrix part of our presentation at briforum london was breaking down the offerings of different daas platforms, and i thought it would make for a useful article for those that werent able to attend. Check out their strong and low points and find out which software is a better option for your company. Citrix edges vmware, microsoft in vdi faceoff network world.
Getting started with vdi zoom help center zoom support. Three areas where citrix xenapp and xendesktop outperform. Compare citrix virtual apps and desktops formerly xendesktop vs vmware horizon. Running zoom as a published app is not currently supported. To use vdi with citrix, you need to purchase citrix virtual apps and desktop formerly citrix xendesktop. For many reasons, this effort was a unique opportunity. Introduction to vmware horizon 7 for citrix administrators vmware. Organizations using citrix xendesktop or vmware horizon server published desktop.
Hard disk, and enter the mac address of the xenapp master image. Compare citrix apps and desktops to vmware horizon no other virtualization solution has innovated so much, or for so long. Citrix winframe vs vmware vsphere high availability ha. Citrix, vmware horizon and remote desktop services a vdi.
Let it central station and our comparison database help you with your research. This is because it turns out that citrix s differentiators of their better product are close if not the same as vmware s. Citrix gives mac client some love searchvirtualdesktop. This solution demonstrates the performance of virtual desktops enabled by vsan 6. In the biggest wow announcement from citrix synergy 2011 san francisco, citrix publicly demoed the delivery a remote mac os x desktop to any client device running the citrix receiver which is available for windows, mac, ios, blackberry, android, webos, etc. Citrix had better support for redirecting hardware usb, scanning, etc over the hdx protocol. Vmware has a vdi offering which is named vmware horizon view now on version 5. Citrix xenapp and xendesktop hdx printing includes the universal printer driver. A key component of the citrix workspace vision, citrix virtual apps and desktops has years of market leadership to ensure the best possible experience for employees and it alike. Dare to compare citrix xenapp vs vmware horizon skype for.
Vmware mirage supports key physical and virtual desktop os and includes byod support for linux, mac, and windows. Citrix, vmware horizon and remote desktop services a vdi comparison. Citrix demos delivering the mac os x desktop to any citrix. Citrix xendesktop problem solving and maintenance is generally a lot more complicated, requiring additional products and thirdparty tools. If you know vsphere, you already know 12 of the software needed to manage a vmware vdi environment. Printing is not important in the vdi environment a. If you are looking at desktop virtualization you would need to compare citrix xendesktop and vmware view. Vmware euc was built with integration points that provide cost savings in. Just to clarify and make some sense ill explain my scenario. Applicatie voor het uitvoeren van meerdere besturingssystemen op een mac. Xenserver is comparable to esxi, however xenapp is not the same as vmware view. Building out citrix xendesktop is a lot more complicated and requires more infrastructure to setup. Application publishing can be useful for delivering virtual apps to desktops, but its really picked up momentum with the proliferation of mobile devices in the workplace.
Parallels desktop business edition brings windows and windows applications to employees on mac and enables integration of mac computers into any work environment from education to financial services. In response to citrix xendesktop 7, vmware recently released horizon 6, the successor to horizon view 5. Citrix has been refining hdx for years with thin clients, so i feel like they do that part better. We compared these products and thousands more to help professionals like you find the perfect solution for your business. Compare citrix virtual apps and desktops to vmware horizon 6 with view to discover why citrix is the industry leader in desktop and app virtualization.
Its clear vmware horizon 6 was developed to wrestle customers from citrix xendesktop and xenapps. Connecting to a remote mac os x desktop has been available for a long time via products like logmein, gotomypc, vnc, etc. Netscaler gateway enabled pcoip proxy support for vmware. A vdi management broker solution from citrix similar to vdi in a box or vmware horizon view, xendesktop is only a vdi management system and still requires a hypervisor server specifically citrix server to function. Pcoip is analogous to citrix hdxica protocol and microsoft rdp protocol. Xendesktop is citrixs vdi system and has been around for many years also.
Im here to get some help, exchange experience and to express my frustration until now with citrix xendesktop and netscaler gateway technologies. Rdp remote desktop or vmware client connect with an rdp protocol is. We were able to obtain citrix receiver for ios, android, mac linuxwindows, and even our blackberryrim playbook2. Citrix releases updated access gateway client for the mac. Citrix virtual apps and desktops formerly xendesktop vs. Vmware cloud on aws is now citrix ready vmware cloud. Xendesktop vs xenapp published full desktop vs esx vdi. Principled technologies, compared microsoft windows 7 virtual desktops hosted on vmware horizon view 5. This session will cover an unbiased and independent performance analysis between citrix virtual desktop and vmware horizon view. In my opinion, horizon is the best option when you dont want to mess around with physical authentication methods like smart cards allied with citrix or other complicated vpns. With this announcement, customers can now select either citrix xendesktop or vmware horizon solutions on vxrail. Application publishing with horizon 6 requires a group of windows servers with the same configuration, also called an rdsh farm. Compare the user experience in xenapp and vmware horizon when starting an application, printing a document and copying a file to a usb drive. Dare to compare citrix xenapp vs vmware horizon view.
We used vmware horizon to connect to a windows environment set up on the customer side overseas by us. Vmware horizon citrix virtual apps and desktops lead the industry in desktop and app virtualization, delivering the only complete solution mobilizing windows apps and desktops for any use case. Other monitoring products rely on the counters built into the os. Were entering an era in which byod is the norm, so vmware and citrix are under intense pressure to provide access, security, and device management, all while giving the end user a consistent experience across any device. Powered by vmware mirage, horizon 6 centralized image management works with physical devices, virtual desktops, and byod. See how many websites are using citrix winframe vs vmware vsphere high availability ha.
True performance testing citrix virtual desktop vs. Home applications citrix releases updated access gateway client for the mac. Use an easy sidebyside layout to quickly compare their features, pricing and integrations. Sidebyside comparison of citrix winframe and vmware vsphere high availability ha. This means a windows 7 virtual desktop can be accessed from a mac or linux pc. The inadequacies of vmware horizon offer more than one. User environment manager share a file share that stores userspecific desktop and application. An indepth look at client drive redirection in vmware horizon. Introduction to vmware horizon 7 for citrix administrators. How do boot camp, parallels desktop, and vmware fusion stack up. It discusses how the citrix components map to a horizon 7 deployment, and the. Furthermore, you can check which one has superior general user satisfaction rating.
Xenapp and xendesktop support client drive redirection from windows, mac os. What do citrix xendesktop and vmware horizon have in. Xenapp is application virtualization, which means running multiple user sessions on a windows server os either published applications or published desktops. More detailed installation instructions can be found on the support pages for citrix here, or for vmware here. Vmware horizon infrastructure upgrades after we published xenapp xendesktop 7. Horizon was vdi only useros until horizon 6 where they added a rds system serveros this was in the last 12 months. Citrix desktop master class approaches to xenapp and xendesktop. Citrix is giving mac users some attention with the citrix receiver for mac clients, which apple accepted into the mac app store. Netscaler gateway enabled pcoip proxy support for vmware horizon view. Years and years ago at the citrix partner summit mark tempelton did a demo which showed off remote access to a mac via xendesktop, obviously a developmental version of the. This means a windows 7 virtual desktop can be accessed from a mac or. This includes horizon and xendesktop virtual desktops, horizon and xenapp published applications and shared desktops, saas applications like salesforce, and applications virtualized by vmware thinapp. Reliably deliver applications in real time to citrix xenapp and.
In the desktop and application virtualization market, vmware has been working to build up products that can compete with the longtime leader in that space citrix. Application for running multiple operating systems on mac. Part of the reason many people own an intelbased mac is because of the possibility of running windows. Clients and protocol both vmware horizon and citrix xenapp support the full spectrum of client devices including android. This includes a collection of additional features like vmware thinapp, vmware vshield endpoint, and horizon view persona management. The vxrail with vmware horizon solution was made available in october, and is enjoying considerable success. Comparison between horizon cloud and citrix cloud on azure.
344 1218 828 1649 1695 1351 799 207 269 1299 561 751 1510 1663 1646 574 1671 976 1551 245 297 880 989 1145 756 769 809 1204 708 1355 1006 293 373 719 1456 787